What does Alberta separatism imply for Canada?

In October, members of Alberta’s governing United Conservative Occasion (UCP) will elect a brand new chief who will grow to be Alberta’s subsequent prime minister.

A defining subject on this management race is Alberta’s place within the Canadian Confederation, with many claimants brazenly discussing “sovereignty,” “autonomy,” and even “independence.”

Are Albertans actually so keen to interrupt ties with the remainder of Canada? Ought to Canadians pay extra consideration to the separatist motion in Alberta? To reply these questions, we appeared to information from the latest Viewpoint Alberta survey.

An infographic that exhibits the important thing findings of the Viewpoint Alberta survey.
creator supplied, creator supplied

Separatism and the Economic system

Help for secession stays a minority view within the province, with one in 5 believing that Alberta ought to “separate from Canada and type an impartial nation.”

This can be a small base from which to construct a province-wide following. But separatists make up a 3rd of the UCP voters – a large constituency for politicians coming to courtroom.

A man in a blue suit stands surrounded by a CTV microphone.
Brian Jean is amongst these to switch outgoing premier Jason Kenny. Their marketing campaign slogan is ‘Autonomy for Alberta’.
Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh

What drives these Alberts to take such a harsh place?

In distinction to the sovereignists pushed by a want to guard their tradition in Quebec, we discover that Alberta separatists are preoccupied with monetary and financial points.

In keeping with our analysis, Alberta’s separatist motion can also be primarily based extra in partisan politics than nationalism.

The separatists place themselves on the precise in comparison with different Alberts. They’re extra more likely to assist conservative political events, each federal and provincial. They usually very a lot dislike the federal authorities and Justin Trudeau.

How dedicated are Alberta separatists?

In our evaluation, we discovered two clues that recommend that assist for separatism is much less a heartfelt want to create a brand new nation and extra a strategic expression of grievances.

The primary is that almost all Albertans – together with the separatists themselves – suppose that secession is unlikely. Barely one in 10 separatists suppose Alberta’s independence is “very probably” or “shall be.”

One other indication is that almost all of separatists (62 p.c) proceed to have an affinity for Canada. The separatists are offended and extra pessimistic about the way forward for the nation.

They haven’t turned their backs on Canada solely; They really feel that that is going within the unsuitable path and desires a significant overhaul.

A man in a white cowboy hat and apron who says the premiere's getaway breakfast serves pancakes to a kid.  The child also wears a white cowboy hat.
Premier Jason Kenney serves pancakes at his final getaway breakfast on July 11 in Calgary. Kenny’s resignation set the stage for a race for the management of the United Conservative Occasion, and a number of other claimants are already discussing Alberta sovereignty.
Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh

pessimism and distrust

The worldview of most separatists relies on a way of lack of status and mistrust for establishments which have fueled populist actions elsewhere on this planet.

They’re extra more likely to really feel that they’re falling behind others in society, and have little belief in governments and the elite. These suspicions drew most separatists to assist the so-called Freedom Convoy, which occupied Ottawa for weeks in February 2022.

Learn extra: What’s a Truck? ‘Azadi Convoy’ protesters going again to Ottawa

Separatists believed that the latest federal election was unfair. This could possibly be as a result of their favourite social gathering misplaced regardless of profitable extra votes, or a perception in conspiracy theories unfold by right-wing information shops.

Regardless of the motive, this low degree of confidence – coupled with a deep sense of pessimism concerning the future – has given rise to actions comparable to Brexit and Trumpism in different components of the world.

separatism in alberta

Whereas assist for secession is a minority view in Alberta, it isn’t a fringe place. The overwhelming majority of separatists assist the UCP provincially and type a big a part of its assist base.

A dark-haired woman stands behind a microphone and smiles.
On this 2014 picture, Danielle Smith, the chief of the Wildroses, is now the lead contender to switch Jason Kenny.
Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh

Such an enormous voting block is wooing the candidates for the management. Hidden guarantees to revive Alberta’s “sovereignty” or safe better “autonomy” might assist promote social gathering membership. They’ll additionally result in victory within the UCP race, forcing the winner to satisfy politically and constitutionally inconceivable guarantees.

However our analysis tells us that flirting with separatism throughout a provincial election is more likely to be flat – if not fully reversed.

The broad Alberta voter is federalist. The bulk don’t assist measures that will additional break up the province from Canada.

Eighty p.c of Albertans disapprove of segregation, and a stable majority additionally oppose the abandonment of the Canada Pension Plan, the RCMP, and federal revenue tax assortment. Most opposed the “freedom convoy” and what it stood for, and the bulk think about most political establishments.

Candidates working for the UCP management have a selection. They could pay lip service to populist and sovereignty positions to realize inner social gathering assist. Or they’ll resist that temptation to win the following provincial election, protect nationwide unity, and strengthen democratic establishments within the course of.

implications for canada

Canadians exterior Alberta ought to maintain a cautious eye on this dynamic. Regardless that they lack the profile of Quebec sovereignists, Alberta separatists are positioned to exert vital political affect on intergovernmental relations within the coming years.

How a lot of an impression is determined by the commitments made by the eventual winner of the UCP management race, and the response from the remainder of Canada to their push for a good deal in Confederation.

If the following prime minister is unable to ship on his guarantees by securing significant concessions from the remainder of Canada, the separatists shall be additional reduce off from the democratic course of. Their despair might result in additional civil unrest, as we noticed from the “freedom convoy”, which provides gasoline to the politics of resentment.

Supply hyperlink