Has Reliance Jio’s entry delayed the imaginative and prescient of Digital India?

Is TRAI’s approval of Jio’s free information an implied indictment of the optical fiber community mission? credit score: The Wire

Reliance Industries Restricted (RIL) has made loads of noise in regards to the Modi authorities’s Digital India mission. The Mukesh Ambani-run agency has constantly promoted its telecom subsidiary Reliance Jio as a key driver of Digital India.

The bottom actuality and preliminary influence of Jio is sort of completely different and Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has performed a key position on this.

Jio’s influence to date has been principally restricted to a rise in city teledensity within the monetary yr ended March 31, 2017, whereas the Common Service Obligation Fund (USOF) – a authorities fund used to construct rural telecom infrastructure – has been decreased to about Rs 1,600 crore.

This shortfall is basically as a result of India’s telecom business’s income has seen a serious drop after Jio’s entry – the contribution to the USOF is predicated on a portion of the entire income. The autumn in income subsequently severely delays the Modi authorities’s formidable mission of offering connectivity to rural and distant areas, which is the spine of Digital India. Former secretary of the Division of Telecommunications (DoT), JS Deepak, who was sacked not too long ago, formally wrote a letter to TRAI chairman RS Sharma, warning on the business’s falling income.

When RIL Chairman Mukesh Ambani launched 4G companies at his AGM in September final yr, he stated: “I want to dedicate the launch of Jio to the Digital India imaginative and prescient of our Prime Minister…” Backdrop Display screen However the Energy Level presentation had a big image of PM Narendra Modi with the caption: “A Tribute to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Realization of Digital India Imaginative and prescient.”

The following day, the duvet pages of main newspapers featured a full-page image of the Prime Minister in Jio ads.

What’s Digital India?

How does Modi outline Digital India – and what are the objectives of this grand mission? Is it offering excessive pace web in city areas at low costs? Or is it about connecting India’s unaffiliated, who make up a big a part of the worldwide unaffiliated?

The IT Ministry defines the imaginative and prescient of Digital India as: “Digital infrastructure as a utility for each citizen, Governance and companies on demand, and Empowerment of the citizen.” The Ministry’s Digital India doc goes into some depth on offering e-learning, well being and e-governance companies as its major goal. The primary targets embody “Offering Public Web in 2.5 lakh villages by March, 2017” and “Broadband to all by March 2017”.

Briefly, Digital India goals to empower the widespread individuals utilizing broadband by offering them e-governance, schooling and well being companies even in distant areas. It goals to bridge the hole between the wealthy and the poor, between rural and concrete areas.

Curiously, the Digital India doc below the NDA authorities was largely ready by RS Sharma, the present chairman of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), when he was the secretary of the IT ministry.

Sharma is now seen as to be biased In the direction of Reliance Jio at the price of the complete business and the Digital India mission.

standing of digital india

As on March 31, 2017, broadband connectivity might be supplied to solely 17,000 GPs in opposition to the goal of two.5 lakh GPs. This clearly reveals that rural areas are nonetheless disadvantaged of broadband. The federal government’s efforts to supply high-speed connectivity in distant and rural areas haven’t been very profitable and personal operators are usually not fascinated by going to distant areas.

Providers like e-learning, tele-medicine and e-governance, that are imagined to empower the widespread individuals, are non-starters for all sensible functions.

city and rural digital divide

Reliance Jio began its companies in September 2016. If we have a look at the TRAI information, it turns into clear that the preliminary influence of Jio has been extra in city areas – the city and rural divide has widened because the firm launched its companies.

City teledensity elevated from 152% to 170% with the primary three months of Jio’s launch, whereas rural elevated from simply 2% to 53%. The share of rural clients declined by 2% to 40.69%.

Rising the City Rural Digital Divide

city space rural half
August, 2016 57.57% 42.43%
December, 2016 59.3% 40.69%
March, 2017 < 60% (estimated) > 40% (approximate)

Affect of Jio on City and Rural Teledensity

city teledensity rural teledensity
August, 2016 152% 51%
December, 2016 170% 53%

It’s clear that the entry of Jio has not directly widened the digital divide between city and rural India. TRAI has not supplied subscriber information since January and it needs to be famous that there was a rise in Jio subscribers within the final three months.

Jio moving into its favor on the subject of Digital India is the excessive utilization of information companies by its clients. The corporate claims to be the most important community globally with over 110 million GB of information site visitors per thirty days and 220 million voice and video minutes per day. Its customers eat virtually the identical quantity of information on all cellular networks in the US and 50% extra information than cellular networks in China.

Nonetheless, the query stays, who’re these clients and what do they do with this information?

If most of those clients are clients in cities, as is clear from the TRAI information and they’re utilizing the information to obtain YouTube movies and play video games, then it’s tough to argue that this has been finished by the federal government in its imaginative and prescient doc. Outlined “Digital India”.

Earlier than the entry of Jio, the telecom penetration within the city space was 150%. This implies there have been 150 telephones for 100 individuals. There have been sufficient choices and other people had the choice of 4G companies. By providing free 4G companies and aggressive advertising, Jio supplied 4G companies to individuals in cities the place present operators had been already providing companies. After the entry of Jio, there are 170 telephones for each 100 individuals.

There isn’t a doubt that the entry of Reliance Jio decreased the tariff for 4G companies because it began providing companies without cost and the rivals additionally decreased the tariff. That is all the time true every time a brand new firm enters the market. Present operators like Airtel, Vodafone and Thought had been pressured to enhance the standard of their companies.

Analysts say Jio’s technique in city India too will influence community high quality in the long term. “There needs to be a sustainable common income per consumer (ARPU) in the long term for the business to outlive. If this doesn’t occur then the complete funding will sink and it’ll have ramifications to destroy the business,” stated former VSNL chairman and managing director BK Singhal. “In the long term, it will solely damage the Digital India program even in cities.”

Singhal blamed the current choices of TRAI Chairman Sharma for the present chaos within the business. “It’s clear that Sharma has failed in his obligation because the custodian of the sector.”

USOF funds crunch

Typically, non-public operators don’t present telecom companies in rural and distant areas as it isn’t economically viable. That is the rationale why the federal government created Common Service Obligation Fund (USOF) to supply connectivity to those locations.

All operators pay 8% of Adjusted Gross Income (AGR) to the federal government as charges, of which 5% goes in direction of USOF contribution.

Jio supplied the companies freed from value for the primary 4 months of its launch. The free information supply was prolonged for an additional three months. Then he made one other supply giving limitless voice and information for 4 months for round Rs 400.

This pressured rivals to decrease tariffs and resulted in decreased business income. This additionally signifies that the license price charged by the federal government has additionally come down.

Telecom Minister Manoj Sinha instructed Parliament that the license price collected by the federal government declined to Rs 3,450.1 crore for the quarter ended December 31, from Rs 3,584.04 crore in July-September and Rs 3,975.7 crore in April-June. Income from spectrum utilization costs declined to Rs 1,553.2 crore in October-December from Rs 1,820.03 crore in July-September and Rs 1,995.2 crore in April-June.

This resulted in a shortfall of Rs 1,600 crore within the allocation of funds to USOF for the monetary yr 2016-17. There was a rise of about Rs 2,300 crore within the fund in 2015-16 as in comparison with the earlier yr. Basically, USOF fund contributions are rising yearly. That is the primary time that the license price assortment has come down drastically.

Fund for USOF

monetary yr UAL Charge Assortment (Crore)
2014-15 7537.88
2015-16 9835.70
2016-17 (Provisional) 8233.53

If funds from USOF run out, it should hamper the Digital India program as its means to ascertain networks in rural areas will probably be severely affected.

Manoj Garola is the editorTelecom Tiger

Supply hyperlink